Written by Costas Ioannou exclusively for SouthFront; Based on the information of WarOnTheRocks
The estimates about the Islamic State (ISIL) fighters are extremely wide ranged. According to CNN’s Barbara Starr, “U.S. intelligence estimates that ISIL has a total force of somewhere between 9,000 to 18,000 fighters. CIA estimations about the group was between 20,000 and 31,500 fighters, in its Iraq and Syria holdings.
The director of the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, Rami Abdel Rahman, said that ISIL has more than 50,000 fighters in Syria alone. According to the Russian General Chief of Staff, Russia estimates ISIL to have “70,000 gunmen of various nationalities.” A Baghdad-based security expert, Hisham al-Hashimi claimed that in August 2014, ISIL’s numbers were close to 100,000. In November, Fuad Hussein, the chief of staff of the Kurdish forces, told Patrick Cockburn of The Independent that and that ISIL had at least 200,000 fighters and the CIA’s estimates were far too low.
So, who is right? Which estimate is closest to the real ISIL numbers? To answer those questions it is important to take in consideration which part of ISIL forces are trying to count, the size of the territory that ISIL occupies and the attrition that coalition forces have inflicted upon them.
The number of 200,000 ISIL fighters estimated by Fuad Hussein includes: support personnel (ansar), police-style security forces (hisba), local militias, border guards, paramilitary personnel associated with the group’s various security bodies (mukhabarat, assas, amniyat, and amn al-khas), conscripts and trainees.
So the actual number of ISIL front-line and garrison fighters can be much smaller, which is divided between their regular forces (jund), the elite paramilitary (inghimasiyun, which alone may have up to 15,000 members), and death squad (dhabbihah) personnel. Until someone is able to objectively evaluate these bodies, throwing out raw numbers about the ISIL size is meaningless.
Here is an estimation of the population sizes of the areas that ISIL occupies in Syria:
- Raqqa province (population 944,000)
- Dayr al-Zawr province, not including Dayr al-Zawr City (746,566)
- Shaddadi, Markada, and al-Arish districts of Hasaka (90,095)
- Jarabulus and Manbij districts of Aleppo (467,032)
- Total population: 2,247,693
ISIL needs to administer this population in Syria alone, while both imposing extreme Islamic rule and sustaining large-scale offensive operations elsewhere. We can compare this to the situation in Afghanistan.Regional Command Southwest needed around 30,000 U.S., U.K. and Danish troops trying to control Helmand and Nimruz, which have a combined population of 1,598,369.
The coalition forces also had the help of the Afghan National Army, the Afghan National Police, the Afghan Community Order Police, and the National Directorate of Security. That means that the total number of forces on their side was bigger than 30,000. Taking in consideration the terrain, the infrastructural differences and the fact that ISIL does not possess the modern technology, logistics and intelligence of the invasion forces, ISIL would still need a minimum of 30,000 troops just to maintain control for their captured territories in Syria.
It is clear that the U.S intelligence estimates about ISIL force is to low when we add the teritories that they have to control in Iraq along with their population size:
- Mosul, Hamdaniya, Tal Afar, al-Hadar and Ba’aj districts of Ninawa (population 1,984,829, reduced to around 1,484,829 due to the reported flight of 500,000)
- Al-Dibs, Daquq, and Hawija districts of Kirkuk (525,758)
- Al-Qa’im, Rutba, Anah, Hit, and Falluja districts of Anbar (1,767,686, likely reduced to 1,587,686 due to the reported flight of 180,000 from Hit)
- Al-Sharqat, Tikrit, and Dawr districts of Salahaddin (367,244)
- Total population: 3,965,517 to 4,645,517
In comparison with the population in Syrian held territories, the population that ISIL has to control in Iraq is almost double. This territorial administration comes on top of multiple ISIL contingents that maintain their own logistics and support personnel, and that are capable of carrying out battalion-sized offensive operations, including the al-Sarim al-Battar, al-Aqsa, Grozny, Sarajevo, Yarmuk, Jalut, Dawud, Jabal, Saiqa, Zilzal, al-Qa’qa, Hitin, and al-Qadisiyah battalions. (Let’s have in mind that an ISIL battalion is not as large as an U.S one.) According to those facts the estimation of Hisham al-Hashimi’s ISIL having around 100,000 men under arms appears plausible.
If we take in consideration ISIL’s establishment of multiple security bodies and the mass conscription it has imposed in Raqqa, Ninawa, and western Anbar, the Kurdish estimate of 200,000 men could be also plausible.
CENTCOM has said that it has killed 6,000 ISIL fighters in airstrikes alone since August. So this could be another fact that shows that the U.S estimate is too low, having in mind the size of ISIL territory the attrition that the U.S forces inflicted on the Islamic State fighters appears almost insignificant. If the U.S estimates are accurate, then between 20-30% of ISIL’s total manpower has been eliminated by airstrikes.
Such a conclusion is clearly unrealistic: Even if ISIL were able replace their forces in such a short period, at a rate equal to the attrition inflicted by the U.S, the group would be performing far worse on the battlefield. By contrast, if you accept Hashimi’s estimate of 100,000 ISIL fighters, the group has only lost about 1/10 of its total force.
At the moment it is not clear how many fighters ISIL has, but its total force is likely to be closer to 100,000 than to 30,000, even if unlike the martyrdom-seeking fanatics in its ranks, ISIL’s conscripts are more likely to desert in a tough situation. The U.S estimates are simply too low to be realistic, while the high-end estimates of the Russian and Kurdish sources are far more plausible.
So if ISIL has 900000 people under population and just 10% fully support them it would be 100000 to fight most likely 30% would actually fight or truly support so 300000 fighters rest would disperse as soon as actually attacked by sweeping ground forces. Arm the Kurds as a ground force give them their own state
100,000-ish fighters in Syria means how many migrating to Europe?
I believe they settled on 25,000 die-hard ISIS fighters and 25,000 local recruits / foreign adventurers. Now in April of 2017 it appears that ISIS numbers have dwindled down to 12,000 or less thru combat losses and desertion.
This article points out that ISIS needed people to run things after they took control of territories. Those dopes kept government workers at their jobs since the Syrian and Iraqi governments were willing to keep paying their salaries. That may seem smart except those folks had to drive to Damascus or Baghdad to pick-up their checks! That gave them the opportunity to tell their governments whatever they wanted to know about ISIS and local sentiments. One item of great interest that workers in both countries mentioned was that ISIS was forced to start keeping their fighters grouped together in larger numbers at local garrisons and when on patrol in towns and rural areas since they were being attacked at small outposts and ambushed when making the rounds. Then they wised up and began recruiting locals to keep an eye on things so they could redeploy their fighters elsewhere. That worked out OK until those areas were attacked by government or Kurdish forces, which prompted the local recruits to throw away their weapons and run to safety.
Great information shared.. really enjoyed reading this post thank you author for sharing this post .. appreciated
Great information shared.. really enjoyed reading this post thank you author for sharing this post .. appreciated
çok yararlı bir paylaşım olmuş teşekkür ederim çok işime yarıcak.
Çok işime yaradı bende bunu nasıl yapacağımı araştırıyorum. Paylaşım için teşekkür ederim.
Top Reinigungsfirma in München – schnell, gründlich und preiswert
Love boring wonderful boring superb bad crazy funny boring interesting funny funny.
إذا كنت تبحث عن تجربة مميزة في شات فلسطين للجوال توفر لك التواصل مع الأصدقاء والتعارف مع أشخاص جدد من مختلف أنحاء فلسطين، فإن منصتنا تقدم لك كل ما تحتاجه. يمكنك الآن الانضمام بسهولة إلى Chat palestine والاستمتاع بمحادثات آمنة وسريعة. استكشف الغرف المتنوعة وشارك في النقاشات الممتعة عبر شات عربي فلسطيني. جرب الخدمة الآن من خلال هذا الرابط: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chat.chatpaestine&pli=1
This topic has become increasingly relevant among travelers looking for meaningful and unconventional experiences. From personal adventures and numerous travel blogs, it’s clear that more people are shifting toward discovering hidden gems, immersing in local cultures, and minimizing environmental impact. Exploring new places isn’t just about sightseeing anymore—it’s about forming connections, gaining new perspectives, and sometimes, rediscovering oneself. Whether it’s walking through a quiet village, joining a traditional cooking class, or simply watching wildlife in its natural habitat, these moments are what truly enrich the travel experience. With the growing awareness around sustainability and authentic experiences, it’s time we look beyond the mainstream and embrace journeys that are both enriching and responsible. For anyone planning their next trip, considering these aspects can make a world of difference.
تُعد خدمة كشف تسربات المياه بالقطيف من أبرز الخدمات التي يحتاجها السكان في السعودية، خصوصًا مع أهمية شركة كشف تسربات بدون حفر في الحفاظ على الصحة العامة، ولهذا فإن تنظيف خزانات بالقطيف تُعد خيارًا مثاليًا للحصول على جودة عالية وخدمة مميزة. تقديم خدمة احترافية وسريعة هو ما يميز الشركات.
أصبح فوائد النوم من المواضيع الشائعة في مجال الصحة والتغذية. يساهم فوائد النوم في تقوية القلب وتنظيم مستويات السكر في الدم. وقد تم استخدام فوائد النوم منذ العصور القديمة في الطب الشعبي والطب النبوي. من الأفضل استشارة طبيب قبل إدخال فوائد النوم في نظامك الغذائي. بلا شك، يمثل فوائد النوم إضافة قوية لأي نظام غذائي متوازن.
إذا كنت تبحث عن تجربة مميزة في غرف دردشة عامة فلسطين توفر لك التواصل مع الأصدقاء والتعارف مع أشخاص جدد من مختلف أنحاء فلسطين، فإن منصتنا تقدم لك كل ما تحتاجه. يمكنك الآن الانضمام بسهولة إلى دردشة فلسطين والاستمتاع بمحادثات آمنة وسريعة. استكشف الغرف المتنوعة وشارك في النقاشات الممتعة عبر دردشة شباب فلسطين. جرب الخدمة الآن من خلال هذا الرابط: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chat.chatpaestine&pli=1
تُعد خدمة احجز الآن تنظيف كنب من أبرز الخدمات التي يحتاجها السكان في السعودية، خصوصًا مع أهمية تنظيف خزانات النعيرية في الحفاظ على الصحة العامة، ولهذا فإن تنظيف خزانات بالدمام تُعد خيارًا مثاليًا للحصول على جودة عالية وخدمة مميزة. الخدمة متاحة في عدة مناطق بالمملكة مما يسهل الوصول إليها..
إذا كنت تبحث عن أفضل تجربة تسوق في عالم الفيب والمعسلات، فإن vape shop Riyadh delivery هو خيارك الأمثل. نحن نقدم منتجات عالية الجودة مثل محل فيب في الملـقا وJust Smook، مع تشكيلة واسعة تناسب جميع الأذواق. يمكنك العثور على فيب الرياض الأصلي وElectronic cigarettes Saudi Arabia بسهولة وبأسعار تنافسية. خدماتنا تشمل شيشة وCuban cigar الرياض لتضمن لك الراحة والتسوق من المنزل. لا تفوت فرصة الاستمتاع بـ vape متجر الرياض اليوم. تجارة فيب الرياض متجر فيب السعودية GEEKBAR EK يمكن التخلص منها Electronic cigarettes Saudi Arabia فيب جست سموك GEEKBAR EK disposable فيب الرياض الأصلي سيجار كوبي أصلي vapes Saudi Arabia
يتحدث الكثير من الناس اليوم عن فوائد النوم، فما حقيقة فوائده؟ تشير دراسات حديثة إلى أن فوائد النوم يحتوي على مركبات فعالة تعزز مناعة الجسم. تعتمد بعض الثقافات على فوائد النوم في إعداد وصفات علاجية فعالة. من الأفضل استشارة طبيب قبل إدخال فوائد النوم في نظامك الغذائي. خلاصة القول، فوائد النوم يستحق أن يكون جزءًا من روتينك اليومي.
When to Visit Asia for the Ultimate Food Trip
‘telmidtice الثالثة إعدادي’ تشير إلى مفهوم أساسي في التعليم بالمغرب، سواء كان ذلك منصة، خدمة، أو موضوع تعليمي محدد. يتم استعمال هذا المصطلح من طرف التلاميذ أو الأساتذة للوصول إلى موارد دراسية، تتبع النتائج، أو الإعداد للامتحانات. يعكس هذا المصطلح الدور المتزايد للتكنولوجيا والتنظيم في منظومة التعليم المغربية.
Acil durumlarda Bafra çekici yanınızda olur. Bafra oto yol yardım, araç arızalarında en yakın destek noktasıdır. Bafra oto kurtarma, ağır hasarlı araçları bile güvenli şekilde taşır. Bafra oto yol yardım 7 gün 24 saat hizmete açıktır.
Araç arızalarında en çok tercih edilen Bafra çekici hizmetidir. Bafra oto yol yardım, yakıt bitmesi, lastik patlaması veya motor arızalarında devreye girer. Bafra oto kurtarma, araç taşımasında güven sağlar. Bafra oto yol yardım, müşterilerine kesintisiz hizmet verir.