Kazakhstan’s Mining Sector Corruption Affecting Russia’s Interests

Kazakhstan’s Mining Sector Corruption Affecting Russia’s Interests

Click to see the full-size image

Written by Ahmed Adel, Cairo-based geopolitics and political economy researcher

The mining sector in Kazakhstan, especially non-fuel, is in a constant state of mired controversies. Coupled with Kazakhstan’s slow opening to the West and growing ethnic nationalism, Russia’s interests in the country is being challenged.

Aurora Minerals Group, which advertises itself as a “full-chain exploration service provider in Kazakhstan and Central Asia” and was founded by so-called veterans of Kazakhstan’s minerals industry, Kaisar Kozhamuratov and Said Sultanov, is the latest to be embroiled in scandal after being implicated in funnelling investors’ money straight into the founders’ pockets. These stories of embezzlement and fraud have become the defining features of Kazakhstan’s mining sector.

The Central Asian country has been attempting to get rid of its image of having one of the world’s most corrupt and inefficient mining sectors in the world according to private financial institutes like Allianz, who gave the country a C4 rating (risky for enterprise) and the World Bank and the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). This has been a struggle to achieve, though.

Adding to the multiple legal disputes and cases of harassment filed by foreign investors, there is an unstable geopolitical situation, especially in the border regions with Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan, which will directly impact Russia. It is within the realm of possibility that the West can conjure an unstable situation on the Kazakh-Russian border.

Kazakhstan is the world’s largest producer of uranium, with almost a third of the world’s uranium coming from the country, ranked top three in estimated reserves of chromium and titanium, top five in copper and zinc, and top 10 in lead, iron ore, coal, and gold. The mining sector forms close to 17% of the country’s GDP. It is seen why the West has a keen interest in challenging Russia in its traditional sphere of influence.

Yet, despite how resource-rich Kazakhstan is, it ranks in the top five countries not to invest among major mining countries and has joined the Democratic Republic of Congo, Mozambique, and Papua New Guinea at the bottom of a list prepared by IHS – S&P Global. Its attractiveness for minor mining companies, especially today, is due to the rapidly expanding technology sector, which requires gold, titanium and other rare earth metals in the circuits and batteries powering AI machines. The most important part is that the Kazakh government owns a majority of the shares in most of the mining companies through its sovereign wealth fund, Samruk-Kazyna.

Despite being an independent country since 1991 and full of rare metals and minerals, the country has not been able to reform its non-fuel mining sector. During the Soviet period, mineral resource extraction and management in Kazakhstan, like in other parts of the Soviet Union, were centrally controlled, focusing on maximising output without significant regard for environmental sustainability or local governance. The post-Soviet transition left Kazakhstan with a legacy of mining licenses and agreements that were issued during the Soviet era, and these licenses were often granted without the competitive bidding processes that are standard today and, in many cases, lacked clear terms and conditions regarding environmental protection, workers’ rights, and revenue sharing.

After gaining independence in 1991, Kazakhstan inherited a vast, under-regulated mining sector. Challenges, including bureaucratic inertia, lack of transparency, and resistance from entrenched interests, still plague the system. The country has made several failed attempts to update its mining laws and regulations to attract foreign investment, improve environmental standards, and increase transparency.

The overlap of old and new regulatory regimes creates opportunities for corruption, including bribery for license approvals, manipulation of tender processes, and illegally extending Soviet-era licenses. New entrants find it difficult to compete on an equal footing with established players holding old licenses.

In this scenario, with the excessive policy risks faced by mining juniors and geopolitical instability due to tensions with its Central Asian neighbours, investors in Kazakhstan will have to take a risky gamble, one which may not pan out in the future. This is critical for Russia, as it is still one of Kazakhstan’s largest trading partners.

Kazakhstan has pledged to abide by Western sanctions against Moscow, and its leader has, in recent years, begun to describe Western nations, such as France, as their strategic partners. Although authorities in Astana are friendly with Moscow, President Qasym-Zhomart Toqaev has been maintaining cooperation with Ukraine and its Western allies. Toqaev has even publicly stated that his country would not recognise the territories formerly in Ukraine liberated by Russian forces.

This comes as a growing conversation and discourse in Kazakh politics, society, and academia revolve around what is now being termed “Russian colonialism/imperialism” in Central Asia rather than integration with the Russian Empire. At the same time, there is a growing rejection of the Russian language in Kazakhstan, with language nationalism growing.

Although it has been mostly Western companies affected by the deep-rooted corruption, especially in the mining sector, as ethnic chauvinism and discourse of Russia’s so-called colonialism of Kazakhstan grows, there is every possibility that the Central Asian country can fall into the same Western trap that Ukraine, Georgia and Armenia fell into, which will inevitably lead to Moscow’s interests being challenged. In fact, liberal philosopher Francis Fukuyama has already started the propaganda by claiming that if Russia is not defeated, “what happened to Ukraine could happen to Kazakhstan,” feeding further the growing anti-Russian elements in the country.

By allowing corruption to be rampant, the West can pay its way to influence Kazakhstan and, if given the opportunity, try to turn the country into another Western-controlled outpost on the borders of Russia, much like Georgia and Ukraine were used.

MORE ON THE TOPIC:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bucuresti

era de inteles si de asteptat un atac pe toată linia… vestul ori se restructureaza ori ajunge la mersul vu caruta din cauza taxelor de mediu impuse companiilor

hash
hashed
jens holm

other funny version of the world.

we in west collapsed nothing there. we fx fight corruption much better. even more pathitic is kasakstan has the same extreme high level as russian and ukraine.

and yes we in eu try to the make better plans. in any production the price has to be clean up. we also has partly by that try to much less fossils.

jens holm

´none says it will be succes all over, but my denmark less and less of fossil in many small steps. we save alot of money, here is cleaner and we are independent.

windpower will make fuel, when it there are extra electrity to periods, where are now.

and no matter what and ukraine eu produce for food then can eat and a part of that is paid me. by that solarpanels fx are better theb potatoes and pigs

jens holm

colonized by amerika i am a nazi moron senile retired uneducated toilet scrubber

amerikan clown show

moron holm lies again —no proof….idiot so corrupt and stupid senile holm insecure like 7 year old girl

Nahavar

corrupt regimes are a risk for russia and the only weapon of the west, the most corrupt regime in the world

hash
hashed
jens holm

far out. you know nothing.

russia, kasakstan and ukraine are max-top in the world corruption. and my denmark is the lowest. .

very much as you has found your esttimtes in your behind. next time use a burning candle.

jens holm

false moron clown—perception of anglo dumb danes is fake reality

Pechorin

submissive amerikan colony damp mark very corrupt like amerrikan dictatorship

jens holm

dumbmark a corrupt amerikan colony

jens holm

thats not related to west at all.

no matter what the pay for minerals go to the oligars and not the proletars and not creating modern jobs.

and where are the many oligarcs, whichtrade with the top in kasakstan.

finaly i have expected for many years those 4 new countries there will find themelves in the hard way in steps fx like duda and orban.

hash
hashed
jens holm

modern job in dumbmark is janitor or night porter same as we were in medieval times

taliban goat herder

is jens holm real or merely an amerikan mutant lizard?

hash
hashed
amerikan clown show

there are no good measures of corruption—only fake perceptions —angl lies from transparency international…no surprise moron holm believes…she cannot think

hash
hashed
Pechorin

there is legal corruption—amerika and colonies devoid of sovereignty like dempmark….there is petty corruption found in asia eastern europe latin amerika and there is stupidity—jens holm

hash
hashed